Voters across Mount Desert Island and neighboring communities defeated a proposed school district reorganization plan on election night, as Mount Desert Islander reported.

The ballot initiative needed majority approval in five specific municipalities to pass: Trenton, Bar Harbor, Mount Desert, Southwest Harbor, and Tremont. While two communities voted in favor of the measure, rejections in the larger island towns effectively killed the proposal.

Tremont was the first community to report its results on election night. By 9:30 p.m., the outcome was clear after Tremont voters defeated the question by a margin of 361 yes votes to 525 no votes. The pattern of rejection continued as results came in from the other participating towns.

In Bar Harbor, electors cast 1,231 votes in favor of the plan and 1,825 votes against it. Mount Desert voters also rejected the reorganization referendum by a vote of 542 yes to 672 no. Southwest Harbor voters turned down the measure as well, with 475 voting yes and 540 voting no.

Conversely, two off-island and outer-island communities supported the reorganization. Trenton voters favored the proposal by a margin of 525 yes votes to 318 no votes. On Frenchboro, voters narrowly approved the plan in a 12 to 10 vote.

Swan’s Island did not report any polling data on the question. A clerical error left the town without a clerk to submit the necessary paperwork required to get the referendum onto the official ballot. Local officials did not note the error until after the 60-day deadline for ballot questions had passed. Superintendent Mike Zboray stated that Swan’s Island will not vote on the reorganization plan now that the proposal has failed to clear the required towns.

Prior to the election, local municipal boards and committees reviewed the plan and offered mixed recommendations, with most municipal bodies advising against passage. The Tremont Selectboard, the Mount Desert Warrant Committee, and the Bar Harbor Town Council all recommended that their respective residents vote against the reorganization. In contrast, the Bar Harbor School Board voted 3 to 2 in August to recommend approval of the plan.

The referendum was the result of four years of work by the Reorganization Planning Committee. Over the past year, the committee held public forums across the island to present its ideas and gather feedback from residents. Throughout the planning process, the committee evaluated several different structural models.

One earlier concept considered by the committee included a proposed island-wide middle school. Another idea was floated to ease financial pressure on towns that had recently made capital investments in their local elementary schools, though that concept was ultimately dropped from the final proposal.

Superintendent Zboray told Mount Desert Islander that he was grateful for the dedication shown by the Reorganization Planning Committee during the multi-year effort. Zboray noted that committee members worked hard and confronted difficult questions while designing the reorganization plan. He added that work still remains to be done regarding district needs.

Zboray explained to Mount Desert Islander that the extended process of planning, gathering public feedback, and holding the vote demonstrated that local residents remain highly engaged with the topic of district reorganization. He indicated that while interest in reorganization persists, deeper conversations are necessary to determine what that structure should look like.

Following the defeat of the referendum, the Reorganization Planning Committee will disband. Any future attempt to bring a new school district reorganization proposal before voters will have to start over from the beginning.

Looking forward, Zboray told Mount Desert Islander that starting these public conversations was an important step for the community. He expressed hope that local discussions will continue to focus on addressing disparities in funding and determining the best educational outcomes for students to ensure they are prepared for high school.